An ODM sample approval should say what was reviewed, which revision was supplied and what the decision covers. A prototype approval, a finish approval and approval of a production reference are not interchangeable. Agree the purpose of each sample before a round starts.
Name the sample stage and its limitations
| Sample purpose | Question it can help answer | Record before approval |
|---|---|---|
| Concept or appearance review | Does the proposed direction match the brief? | Represented features and unresolved construction |
| Engineering prototype | Which design requirements can be evaluated at this stage? | Materials, processes and parts that differ from the intended production build |
| Pre-production review | Does the proposed production configuration meet the agreed review scope? | Process and material references, evidence and open actions |
| Approved reference or golden sample | Which physical reference accompanies the controlled specification? | Identity, approval scope, custody and revision |
Names vary between projects. Define them in the brief rather than assuming that both parties mean the same thing. A visual prototype should not silently become evidence for a production performance claim.
Prepare a sample request that exposes unknowns
Include intended use, drawings, materials, finish, configuration, packaging needs and the questions the sample must resolve. Mark proposed substitutions and features not yet represented. Link to the relevant technical-pack revision.
Ask the supplier to propose stage-specific work, timing and dependencies. Do not treat a general sample estimate as a guaranteed turnaround for every design. Materials, tooling, approvals and testing requirements need confirmation for the project.
Use one review record
Assign each observation an identifier. Record the location, expected requirement, observed result, supporting image and responsible reviewer. Separate accepted features, requested changes and questions awaiting evidence. Consolidate conflicting feedback before sending the next revision.
For every requested change, identify the affected drawing, part or finish reference. Ask whether it changes the scope of other assessments. Avoid approving a revised sample from photographs when the agreed requirement needs physical measurement or other evidence.
Sign off the golden sample without replacing the specification
Label the physical reference with model and revision, approval date and reviewer. Record any exceptions. Specify where reference samples and controlled photographs are retained and how both parties identify the same version.
The golden sample supports the written specification; it does not replace dimensions, material records, instructions or test evidence. Keep any approved deviations explicit. A worn or damaged reference should not quietly become the standard for future orders.
Release the next stage deliberately
Before authorising production or another development stage, check that the open-action list and the approved documents agree. Record which items are closed and which remain conditions of release. Confirm tooling responsibilities and any project-specific rights in the agreement rather than inferring ownership from sample approval.
Send your sample brief with the intended decision, current revision and unresolved requirements. Clear stage definitions make supplier responses easier to compare and keep later changes traceable.
Frequently asked questions
Is a prototype the same as a pre-production sample?
Not necessarily. Define each stage’s purpose, materials, processes and limitations in the project brief. Approval should apply only to the recorded scope.
What should a golden sample record contain?
Include model and revision, approval date, reviewer, accepted scope, exceptions and reference custody. Keep it linked to the controlled specification and supporting evidence.
How long does an ODM sample take?
Timing must be confirmed for the project and stage, including material availability, development work, approvals and assessment requirements. This guide does not promise a fixed turnaround.
What happens when a sample changes after approval?
Record the changed revision, affected requirements and the checks or approvals that need repeating. Do not silently substitute a new sample for the approved reference.